The book that will not leave you alone

If you have more than one book idea and cannot tell which one God is asking for, three plain questions will usually show you. The answer is often the one you have tried hardest to put down.

Maybe it is one idea. More often it is three.

A devotional from the year everything fell apart. A study you have taught in pieces for a decade. A story about your father you have never told all the way through. And underneath all three sits one question that keeps the laptop closed. Which one is from God? Is any of them?

It is an honest question, and a good one. Whoever asks it is taking the work seriously, and nobody wants to spend two years on a book God never asked for.

But waiting for a voice from heaven before choosing can become its own kind of hiding. So let me offer three plain questions. None of them is magic. Together they usually point somewhere.

First, which idea keeps coming back?

Ideas born from ambition tend to burn hot and fade. We get excited for a week, then something shinier comes along. The book God puts in a person behaves differently. It goes quiet for a season and then shows up again. In the car. In the shower. In the middle of someone else’s sermon. Years later it is still there.

Jeremiah knew that pull better than most.

“If I say, ‘I will not mention Him or speak any more in His name,’ His message becomes a fire burning in my heart, shut up in my bones, and I become weary of holding it in, and I cannot prevail.” (Jeremiah 20:9, BSB)

Jeremiah tried to quit. He actually said the words out loud. And the message would not let him go. A calling often feels that way from the inside. It is rarely a lightning bolt. Far more often it is a slow fire you can no longer pretend is out.

Second, which idea have you lived?

The book you are meant to write usually grows out of your own ground. A season you walked through. A truth you learned the hard way, in front of real people. You can borrow a topic from anyone. You cannot borrow the years that taught you what you know about it.

Third, can you picture the person it is for?

One real face. Maybe a young pastor who keeps asking you the same question over coffee. Maybe a friend who just buried her husband. If a face comes to mind for one idea and none comes for the others, pay attention to that.

Run every idea through those three questions. One usually stands a little taller than the rest.

And if two still tie? Pick one and begin. God does not hide His will behind a combination lock. He is glad to steer a person who is moving, far more than one standing still and waiting to be certain.

The other ideas are not lost. Write them on a card and put it in a drawer. Some of them may be your second book.

So take the one that will not leave you alone, and write one honest page of it this week. If the fire is already there, the hardest part is done.


If you want the whole road laid out in the order it actually happens, I put together a free checklist called The Lightkeeper Path. It is yours.